Obsessive Compulsive Personality Disorder vs. Autism
Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Disorder (OCPD) and its many hidden complexities is somewhat like that eccentric vagabond cousin in the family tree – the cousin is there and vaguely remembered but poorly understood. Given that OCPD is so poorly understood, I was surprised to learn it is the most common of the personality disorders, with an estimated lifetime prevalence rate between 3% and 8% within the general population. Even more striking are the high numbers of OCPD in clinical settings, where estimates suggest 8.7% among outpatients and a notable 23.3% in inpatient environments (Rizvi, 2023). Yet, despite these significant numbers, OCPD is relatively under-researched and often relegated to the periphery of psychiatric studies. OCPD remains shrouded in subtlety, its intricate layers frequently overlooked in psychiatric discourse.
OCPD and autism, despite distinct diagnostic criteria, share overlapping traits and potentially common genetic underpinnings, as highlighted by Gadelkarim et al. (2019). This overlap can lead to diagnostic complexities, where one condition might overshadow the other or result in misdiagnoses, impacting the understanding and treatment of individuals. As an Autistic psychologist with significant OCPD tendencies, I'm personally invested in exploring these intricacies. This article will delve into the nature of OCPD, examining how it aligns with and diverges from autism. By exploring the diagnostic challenges and psychological underpinnings of these experiences, I hope to offer a deeper understanding of their relationship and their individual characteristics.
Contents:
OCPD Overview
Prevalence of OCPD
Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Disorder, while seemingly less dramatic than its counterparts in the spectrum of personality disorders, stands as a significant presence in both the general and clinical populations. Studies indicate a varied prevalence, suggesting a range of 3% to 8% in the general population, a figure that rises markedly in clinical settings. These numbers paint a picture of a condition that, despite its subtlety, exerts a pervasive influence on a considerable segment of society.
The clinical significance of OCPD extends beyond these statistics. Its under-researched status conceals the profound impact it has on individual lives. This gap in research and understanding points to a need for deeper exploration, both in terms of prevalence and in the unique challenges it presents in diagnosis, treatment, and management.
OCPD and Autism
The intersection of OCPD with autism presents a fascinating yet complex diagnostic challenge. Both conditions share a range of behavioral and cognitive traits, yet they stem from fundamentally different origins. This overlap can lead to a misdiagnosis or to diagnostic overshadowing, where the presence of one condition may obscure or complicate the accurate identification of the other. In cases of diagnostic overshadowing, individuals may present with both conditions, a common co-occurrence, and one is identified while the other is missed. One study found that 54% of an adult population with OCPD also met criteria for autism. Interestingly, the Autism diagnosis had been missed while clinicians had identified OCPD (Gadelkarim et al., 2019).
The shared traits between OCPD and autism, such as a preference for routine, a focus on details, and challenges in adapting to change, call for a nuanced understanding of both experiences. Genetic underpinnings, environmental factors, and developmental pathways play a role in this intersection, making it a rich area for further research and clinical exploration. Understanding the similarities and differences between OCPD and autism is crucial for accurate diagnosis, effective treatment planning, and improved outcomes for Autistic people with OCPD.
The Psychological Landscape of OCPD
OCPD Traits: The Shadow of Doom and Doubting Mania
At the heart of Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Disorder lies a tormenting psychological phenomenon: the “shadow of doom” or the "doubting mania,” a term coined by psychoanalyst Nancy McWilliams. This shadow of doom is akin to an ever-looming sense of impending failure, where individuals constantly anticipate things going wrong, a flaw being exposed, or a profound loss of control. The doubting mania extends to self-doubt, doubt of others, and doubt of the world at large. Within this relentless questioning, an obsessive adherence to rules, order, and perfectionism becomes a protective shield.
Autonomy and control are central to OCPD, yet they create a painful paradox. Individuals with OCPD often find themselves in a paradoxical loop: their intent to keep every option open — an effort to maintain control over every possible outcome — ironically leads to a state where no real choices remain. As noted by McWilliams, this hyper-vigilance toward autonomy ironically becomes the force that undermines it, creating a self-imposed prison where action is reflexive, stripped of the freedom found in thoughtful contemplation.
The undercurrents of OCPD often stem from a profound fear of imperfection and a relentless pursuit of control. Dr. Kirk Honda posits that “flaw shame” (shame about perceived flaws) is at the heart of this condition. This pursuit of perfection, while seemingly proactive, often leaves individuals in a state of constant pre-emption, always trying to forestall potential flaws at the cost of experiencing genuine autonomy and freedom of thought.
OCPD Traits: The Labyrinth of Shame
Another fundamental aspect of OCPD is its intricate emotional interplay, deeply rooted in shame and an overarching need for control. For those with OCPD, their inner world is often a tortuous maze dominated by an overwhelming fear of making mistakes or being perceived as flawed. Criticism is not merely feedback but is experienced as a profound personal affront, further entrenching the individual in a rigid mindset where only absolute correctness is acceptable.
This inflexibility often stems from unresolved internal conflicts: a latent rage about lost control intermingles with an overwhelming desire to sidestep guilt and shame. These feelings, rooted in childhood experiences of overcontrol or neglect, fuel a relentless cycle. The person constantly strives to meet self-imposed expectations and standards, which they may also project onto others.
OCPD's association with parental overcontrol is well-known, but it can also arise from neglect. In the absence of nurturing guidance, these individuals often construct an idealized, societal norm-based image of parenting, against which they relentlessly measure themselves (McWilliams).
Importantly, while many with OCPD exhibit both obsessive and compulsive traits, these are distinct constructs. Those with obsessive tendencies within the OCPD spectrum often anchor their self-worth in cognitive processes, seeking to allay anxiety by thinking things through. In contrast, those with compulsive tendencies act to resolve anxiety (for example: compulsively working), as noted by McWilliams.
When external situations impede these self-validation methods, individuals with OCPD may spiral into deep depression. McWilliams observes that both obsessive and compulsive personalities harbor a fear of their own hostility. This results in excessive self-criticism for both real and imagined wrongdoings. The resultant internal conflict is a perpetual struggle between thought and action, leaving individuals in a relentless quest for equilibrium in a world where unending perfection and correctness are demanded.
Features of OCPD
The Facade of Efficiency and Success
Individuals with Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Disorder often exemplify success and efficiency. Excelling in academics and professions, their image of confidence and meticulous organization is notable. Yet, this external success often conceals a struggle which is primarily internal and relational. The hidden turmoil of OCPD manifests in the stress and strain experienced in personal interactions, revealing the disorder's profound impact on emotional and social well-being.
The Chameleon-like Nature of OCPD
OCPD is characterized by deep-seated fear and shame surrounding personal flaws and an underlying resentment towards being controlled. Despite these core elements, OCPD presents itself in various forms, making it a particularly chameleon-like disorder. The root lies in perfectionism, but its expressions are diverse, ranging from obsessions with neatness and orderliness to stringent financial management, and from rigid time management to excessive devotion to work and productivity (Honda, 2022). These varied manifestations underscore the complex nature of OCPD and layering the individual's psychological and behavioral profile.
OCPD Subtypes and Spectrum of Perfectionism
Recognizing the spectrum of OCPD is crucial for understanding its complexity. The disorder spans a range of subtypes, each marked by a distinct expression of perfectionism, including:
Self-Punishing Perfectionism: A tendency where individuals are overly critical of themselves, often leading to a cycle of self-blame and guilt.
Compulsive Tendencies: Behaviors characterized by a need for order, control, and meticulous attention to detail.
Self-Righteous Attitudes: A mindset where individuals believe strongly in their own moral and ethical standards, often leading to judgmental views of others.
Workaholism: An excessive devotion to work at the expense of personal and leisure time.
Obsession with Learning and Knowledge: A compulsive pursuit of intellectual growth, often to the detriment of social interactions and other interests.
Body or Health Perfectionism: An overwhelming focus on body perfection, physical fitness or health, sometimes leading to unhealthy behaviors and sometimes overlapping with eating disorders.
Hoarding or Miserly Behaviors: Difficulty discarding items or an excessive reluctance to spend money, driven by fears of waste or financial insecurity
(Reference: Dr. Honda, 2022)
Symptoms of OCPD
OCPD DSM-5 Criteria
The DSM-5-TR provides both categorical and dimensional approaches to diagnosing OCPD, focusing on a consistent pattern of behavior characterized by an excessive need for orderliness, perfectionism, and control, often at the expense of flexibility and efficiency.
In the traditional categorical method of diagnosing personality disorders, each disorder is viewed as a distinct entity with specific criteria. For OCPD, diagnosis requires that a person exhibits at least four of the following characteristics, which should appear in late adolescence or early adulthood and be observable in various settings, causing significant distress:
Preoccupation with Details, Rules, and Organization: An overwhelming focus on minute details, stringent adherence to rules, and a compulsive need for systematic organization, often at the expense of the main objectives.
Perfectionism Hindering Task Completion: A fixation on perfection that interferes with task completion, leading to procrastination, missed deadlines, or an avoidance of projects due to fear of exposing flaws.
Excessive Devotion to Work, Neglecting Leisure and Relationships: An inability to relax or “switch of” from work, resulting in the neglect of leisure activities and personal relationships.
Inflexibility about Morals and Ethics: A rigid adherence to personal moral and ethical codes, potentially leading to judgmental attitudes and conflicts.
Difficulty Discarding Useless or Worn-Out Items: Struggling to let go of items without practical use or value, often due to a sense of responsibility or fear of wastefulness.
Reluctance to Delegate Tasks: Stemming from perfectionism and a fear that others won't complete tasks correctly, leading to excessive workloads and a belief that only they can do tasks the “right” way.
Miserly Spending Habits: An excessive reluctance to spend money, sometimes to the extent of self-deprivation, often driven by fear of financial instability.
Rigidity and Stubbornness: An inflexible adherence to personal routines, resistance to change, and difficulty adapting to new situations or viewpoints.
The Clinical Challenge and the Perfectionist Mindset
The deceptive presentation of OCPD poses a significant clinical challenge. Patients might appear highly functional, but this often masks the disorder's true impact. Insights from family members and close associates who witness the strain of perfectionism in everyday contexts are crucial for a comprehensive understanding. At its core, OCPD is driven by a relentless pursuit of perfection, leading to internal conflict and strained relationships. The inflexibility in beliefs and the conviction that their way is the only right way can cause relational breakdowns. However, in certain professional environments, this meticulous nature can be an asset, showcasing the complex and multifaceted nature of OCPD.
OCPD and Autism
OCPD and Autism: Navigating Diagnostic Complexity
The overlap between OCPD and autism adds layers of complexity to the diagnostic process. Studies indicate a significant overlap in symptoms and traits, leading to potential misdiagnosis or missed diagnosis. In some cases, OCPD traits may overshadow autistic traits or vice versa, necessitating a nuanced understanding and careful consideration in the diagnostic process. Recognizing the unique characteristics of each condition is vital to avoid diagnostic overshadowing and ensure accurate identification and support.
OCPD vs Autism: Overlapping Symptoms and Distinguishing Features
Both OCPD and autism share symptoms like a strong preference for routines, difficulty adapting to changes, and perfectionistic tendencies. However, discerning the motivations and underlying challenges that differentiate them is essential. In OCPD, behaviors are often driven by a fear of imperfection and a need for control. Meanwhile, in autism, they may be more linked to unique cognitive processing styles and sensory sensitivities.
Understanding these distinctions is crucial in providing appropriate support. For OCPD, this might involve addressing unconscious conflicts and modifying core schemas – deeply held beliefs about oneself and the world. In contrast, supporting an Autistic person often focuses on building accommodations tailored to their individual brain style and developing effective self-soothing strategies. Therefore, supporting an individual who is Autistic and also has OCPD involves a nuanced combination of these approaches. It requires addressing the unique aspects of both conditions – tackling the unconscious conflicts and core schemas related to OCPD, while simultaneously building accommodations and supporting the innate brain style and self-soothing strategies beneficial for autism.
While the focus of this article is on distinguishing OCPD from autism, it is important to note that OCPD and autism can also co-occur. In fact, research has shown a high degree of overlap between Autism and OCPD (Gadelkarim et al., 2019).
Distinguishing Autism from OCPD
To develop appropriate support and care, it is critical to thoroughly understand the distinct experiences, challenges, and motivations inherent in autism and OCPD. Clinicians are tasked with navigating the nuanced differences and similarities between these conditions which ensures that diagnostic and therapeutic approaches are tailored to meet specific individual needs.
The following section delves deeper into behaviors common to both conditions, exploring how their fundamental nature differs between an OCPD presentation and an Autistic presentation. This exploration is based on clinical observations and my own hypotheses. It is important to note that further research in this area is highly warranted.
Indecision, Task Paralysis, and Procrastination
Both individuals with OCPD and autism often experience indecision, task paralysis, and procrastination, but their origins and implications differ.
OCPD Task Paralysis, Procrastination and Indecision
In the context of OCPOD procrastination and indecision is often related to:
Fear of Making the Wrong Choice: The dread of error in OCPD is tied to potential guilt or shame. This anxiety leads to a hesitation in decision-making, as the goal is a perfect, error-free choice.
Perfectionism and Shame: At the core of OCPD is the fear of making a mistake and facing the associated shame. This leads to a delay in decision-making as a protective mechanism against the turmoil of imperfection.
Autism Task Paralysis, Procrastination, and Indecision
In the context of autism, we also often struggle with task initiation and paralysis, procrastination and decision-making. This is often related to:
Executive Functioning Challenges: This involves complexities in decision-making, stemming from difficulties in planning and organizing tasks. Individuals may struggle to know where to start, which can significantly impede task initiation and progression.
Autistic Inertia: This term describes the difficulties that Autistic individuals often face in initiating new tasks. It goes beyond simple procrastination; it is linked to the challenges in shifting focus or transitioning between activities. This difficulty is characteristic of a “monotropic focus,” where shifting attention from one interest or activity to another can be particularly challenging.
Autistic Catatonia: In addition to inertia, some individuals may experience Autistic catatonia, which involves motor shutdowns. This condition can significantly impact the ability to start new tasks, as it often leads to periods where the individual becomes immobile or unresponsive to external stimuli.
Motor Movement Difficulties: Challenges with coordinating motor movements are also a common aspect of autism. These difficulties can manifest as clumsiness or uncoordinated motor skills, further complicating the process of initiating and engaging in new tasks. These motor challenges can be mistaken for reluctance or hesitation, but they are actually neurological in nature.
Demand Avoidance: A distinct feature of autism is a resistance to external demands, which differs significantly from general avoidance. This resistance is not about defiance; rather, it is deeply rooted in the need for self-directed control. Autistic individuals may experience a fight-or-flight reaction to situations where they perceive a loss of autonomy or face overwhelming sensory input and energy demands. While at first glance, this drive for autonomy might appear similar to the control-seeking behaviors seen in OCPD, it's important to recognize that the underlying motivation in autism is neurologically based. This neurological basis fundamentally influences how autistic individuals process and respond to external demands.
Key Distinction
In OCPD, indecision is driven by a desire to protect from imperfection and the shame of making the wrong choice; whereas in autism, indecision is linked to cognitive processing style and executive functioning challenges.
Dichotomous Thinking: OCPD vs. Autism
Dichotomous thinking, also known as all-or-nothing thinking, is common in both OCPD and autism.
OCPD Dichotomous Thinking
For individuals with OCPD, dichotomous thinking often aligns with a perfectionist worldview. This black-and-white perspective can be a way of coping with anxiety and a need for control and predictability.
This thinking style can manifest in OCPD as a rigid adherence to rules, procedures, and a strong sense of what is “right” or “wrong.” It's a way to manage the distress caused by uncertainty and maintain a sense of order and predictability.
Autistic Dichotomous Thinking
In contrast, for many Autistic people, dichotomous thinking can be more reflective of a cognitive processing style. It's not so much driven by anxiety or a need for control, but rather a preference for clear, unambiguous information.
This cognitive style might lead to challenges with understanding nuances and gray areas, especially in social situations and communication. Autistic individuals often have a precise way of interpreting language and actions, which can make it difficult to navigate situations where subtlety and indirect expressions are common.
Key Distinction
In OCPD, dichotomous thinking is about maintaining control and perfectionism. In autism, it's about cognitive processing preferences and clarity in a complex world.
Preoccupation with Details, Rules, and Organization
A preoccupation with details, rules, order and systematizing are common both among Autistic people and people with OCPD, but are driven by different mechanisms.
OCPD Preoccupation with Details, Rules, and Organization
Fear of Failure and Need for Control: Individuals with OCPD often have an intense focus on details, driven by anxiety about imperfection and a desire to exert control over their environment.
Perfectionism: This drive for perfection, a way to fend off feelings of shame, manifests in a strict adherence to order, rules, and details. Additionally, the sense of incompleteness when things are left disordered can be distressing for those with OCPD.
Autism Preoccupation with Details, Rules, and Organization
Cognitive Style and Special Interests: For Autistic individuals, attention to details is often part of our inherent cognitive style and is usually connected to our intense interests.
Special Interest Categorization: Many autistic people find comfort in cataloging and organizing data, especially related to our special interests. This behavior ties into our monotropic focus and the use of repetition as a form of self-soothing. Unlike OCPD, these activities are not primarily driven by anxiety.
Comfort in Predictability: Structured routines and explicit rules provide a sense of comfort in what might otherwise feel like a chaotic world.
Context Independence: Autistic individuals often experience what is known as “context independence” (alternatively described as “context blindness”). This means that social rules and norms are not intuitively absorbed; hence, we rely more on explicit rules and norms to navigate social situations. This reliance on explicit rules compensates for the challenges in picking up unwritten social cues.*
Key Distinction
In OCPD, the intense focus on details is primarily an anxiety-driven response. At its core, it revolves around a need for control and a drive for perfection, often leading to stress and discomfort when perfection is not achieved.
In contrast, for Autistic people this focus is not born out of anxiety but rather stems from a search for coherence and a clear set of expectations. We often find genuine enjoyment in delving into the details or categorizing areas of interest. This difference is crucial: in OCPD, the behavior is anxiety-driven, whereas in autism, it can be a source of satisfaction and joy.
The Need for Predictability, Routine and Structure
Both people with OCPD and Autistic people rely a great deal on routine, structure and predictability; however, the root cause is different.
OCPD Need For Predictability, Routine and Structure
Control and Perfectionism: In OCPD, a strong need for sameness and predictability stems from a deep-seated desire to maintain control and achieve perfection. This need is often a method to minimize the uncertainty that could lead to errors or perceived failures.
Anxiety Management: Adopting predictable routines is also a strategy for managing underlying anxiety. By adhering to known patterns, individuals with OCPD can alleviate feelings of stress associated with unpredictability.
Emotional Regulation: In OCPD, the drive for control and predictability often ties into emotional regulation. By maintaining strict routines and predictability, individuals with OCPD might feel more emotionally stable and less prone to the distress that unpredictability can bring.
Autistic Need For Predictability, Routine and Structure
Sensory and Cognitive Processing: For Autistic people, the reliance on routine is often linked to managing sensory sensitivities and achieving cognitive comfort. Predictable routines can help in managing sensory sensitivities, as familiar environments and activities are less likely to present overwhelming or distressing sensory input. These routines also provide cognitive comfort, helping to reduce cognitive load and make the world more navigable.
Autistic Inertia: Challenges with changes in routine are partly due to autistic inertia, where shifting attention or altering established routines can be inherently difficult. This is not just a preference for consistency but is deeply rooted in the way Autistic brains process information and handle transitions. Autistic inertia can make adapting to changes in routine particularly challenging, and sudden changes can be disorienting or distressing.
Key Distinction
In OCPD, the pursuit of predictability, routine, and structure is primarily driven by a need for control and anxiety management; while in autism, it relates more to managing sensory sensitivities, managing sensory demands, and achieving cognitive comfort.
Workaholism and Drive For Productivity
A tendency toward workaholism and difficulty relaxing can be common in both OCPD and autism.
OCPD Workaholism
Driven by Control and Perfection: For individuals with OCPD, an intense work ethic often stems from a deep need for control and an aversion to making mistakes. Work becomes a crucial means of upholding high standards and managing anxiety.
Self-Worth Tied to Productivity: Self-esteem and productivity are often equated, leading to difficulty in relaxing and viewing non-productive time as wasteful.
Autism Workaholism
Comfort in Routine and Structure: Many Autistic people immerse themselves in work or focused activities because these environments provide predictability and structure. This setting offers comfort and a sense of stability.
Deep Engagement in Special Interests: Engaging in work or tasks, particularly those that align with their special interests, can be deeply satisfying and captivating, providing a profound sense of engagement and fulfillment. Additionally engagement with special interests helps to block distressing emotions and stimuli and is a form of self-soothing.
Key Distinction
While workaholism in OCPD is primarily a strategy to manage anxiety related to control and perfection, in autism, it often stems from a need for structured activities and a deep engagement in areas of personal interest.
Other Areas of Overlap
High Morality/Value-Driven Tendencies
Both individuals with Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Disorder (OCPD) and Autistic persons exhibit a tendency towards rigidity in their moral and ethical beliefs, although for different reasons. For individuals with OCPD, the rigidity in moral and ethical beliefs often stems from a need for control and an underlying anxiety. Moral and ethical rigidity can be a way of imposing order and predictability in a world perceived as chaotic or unreliable. This can lead to inflexibility, strict adherence to rules, and sometimes quick judgments about right and wrong.
Autistic people can also have strict adherence to moral codes and values. Autistic people tend to be very value-driven. Aswisely noted by Terra Vance, “Autistic people don’t simply have values and passions, we are our values and passions.” Many Autistic people have a strong sense of justice or fairness and can be deeply committed to their moral convictions. This isn't typically about control or anxiety but rather a part of an intrinsic experience of self and understanding of the world. This can sometimes lead, however, to interpersonal challenges or misunderstanding perspectives that differ significantly from our own.
Social Interactions and Interpersonal Difficulties
Social difficulties in OCPD may arise from rigidity and high expectations, especially when there is limited insight and a tendency to project desires for order and perfection onto others. In autism, challenges often stem from difficulties interpreting non-autistic (allistic) social cues, the sensory demands of socializing, or the effort required to mask Autistic traits.
Additionally, both groups may experience social difficulties related to criticism and shame. For people with OCPD, criticism can trigger a strong defensive reaction due to their worst fear being realized (exposure of flaws), leading to responses of shame or anger. Autistic individuals might struggle with criticism due to rejection-sensitive dysphoria or a history of misunderstanding and victimization, potentially leading to shutdowns or anger.
Specialized Interests
Intense and specialized interests are hallmark aspects of autism, often associated with great joy. Conversely, in OCPD, an intense focus on specific topics or skills may develop as part of a pursuit for mastery or perfection. This shared characteristic, while stemming from different motivations, highlights another interesting area of overlap between the two experiences.
Distinct Autistic Traits and OCPD Traits
In addition to exploring the functions behind shared behaviors, it's important to recognize the distinctively Autistic traits that set them apart from those typically found in OCPD.
Distinct Autistic Traits
Sensory Diversity: Individuals with autism often experience intense sensory perceptions, ranging from hypersensitivity, where sensations are overwhelming, to hyposensitivity, where they are understated. A key aspect is interoception, the awareness of internal body sensations, which varies significantly among individuals. Notable sensory differences in interoception and proprioception may indicate the presence of autism.
Autistic Brain Style: The Autistic mind typically employs a bottom-up processing style, focusing on details before the whole. This concrete thinking is often paired with monotropism, an intense focus on specific interests, providing joy and a unique way of engaging with the world.
Distinct Autistic Communication Patterns: Autistic communication is usually direct, concrete, and straightforward. Autistic people often prefer meaningful discussions over small talk, focusing on the core of the conversation.
Neurological Distinctiveness: Autism is a distinct neurotype from birth, characterized by a sensitive nervous system and unique ways of processing, experiencing, and interacting with the world.
Distinct OCPD Traits
Pathological Perfectionism: Unlike mere attention to detail, pathological perfectionism in OCPD involves an overwhelming need for orderliness and perfection. This trait can significantly impact task completion, leading to personal suffering due to a loss of flexibility and efficiency.
Persistent Productivity: Individuals with OCPD often feel a compelling need to be constantly productive. They may struggle to relax or engage in activities they perceive as “non-productive.”
Core Defense Mechanism: The development of OCPD is often a defense mechanism against deep fears of imperfection and losing control. This complex psychological process serves as a shield against intense feelings of shame, driving individuals towards a relentless pursuit of perfection. The defense mechanisms in OCPD are typically “ego-syntonic,” meaning they align with the individual's self-perception, making them challenging to recognize as problematic. This can create barriers to seeking treatment, as the behaviors feel integral to the person's identity. Despite these challenges, OCPD results in significant personal struggles and necessitates both understanding and appropriate treatment.
Summary
Understanding the nuanced differences between OCPD and autism is crucial for accurate diagnosis and effective support. While both conditions may present with similar behaviors such as a preference for routine, detailed focus, and difficulties with change, the underlying motivations and experiences are distinctly different.
In OCPD, behaviors are often driven by a deep need for control and perfectionism, a fear of making mistakes, and an overarching desire to adhere to self-imposed standards. These individuals may exhibit rigidity in their beliefs, a relentless pursuit of order, and a strong reaction to criticism, reflecting a need to manage underlying anxiety and avoid perceived failure.
On the other hand, in autism, these behaviors are typically rooted in the individual's intrinsic processing style. Challenges with social interactions, preference for structure, and detailed focus are less about control and more about finding coherence in a world that operates on our unique wavelength. Our actions are often driven by sensory processing needs, cognitive comfort, and an authentic alignment with personal values. Specialized interests and routines provide predictability and reduce anxiety in a world that can feel overwhelming.
Complicating matters, there is a high prevalence rate of Autistic people among those diagnosed with OCPD, so a person may both be Autistic and have OCPD. Thus, teasing apart these conditions and identifying co-occurrence requires careful consideration of the individual's emotional drivers, their response to change and criticism, and the underlying reasons for their structured behaviors. A nuanced understanding of these motivations is key to providing empathetic and effective support tailored to each individual's needs and experiences.
OCPD Resource and OCPD Tests
Understanding and supporting individuals with OCPD or autism involves thorough assessments and evaluations. While a clinical diagnosis is essential, some online screeners can offer preliminary insights.
OCPD Screeners
Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Test: A screening tool that can provide initial data points. Access the test here.
POPS: Another useful screener for initial consideration. Take the test here
Keep in mind, these tests are not substitutes for professional diagnosis but can be a first step towards understanding and seeking further evaluation.
Autism Screeners
Screeners like the AQ (Autism Spectrum Quotient) and CAT-Q are available for preliminary understanding of autistic traits. Explore a list of autism screeners here.
Additional Resources
OCPD Fact Sheet: Detailed information on OCPD. View the fact sheet.
OCPD Deep Dive (Podcast) by Dr. Honda: Offers in-depth discussions on personality disorders. Available on his Patreon. Visit Dr. Honda's Patreon.
The OCPD Foundation: A community and support resource for individuals with OCPD.
*Context Independence” is a term coined by Dr. Amara Brook as an alternative to the widely held term “context blindness” which refers to the Autistic person’s inability to perceive contextual cues. Context independence highlights how our behavior, actions, and norms tend to be independent of context and authentic across multiple contexts.
References
American Psychiatric Association. (2022). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (5th ed., text rev.). American Psychiatric Publishing.
Gadelkarim W, Shahper S, Reid J, Wikramanayake M, Kaur S, Kolli S, Osman S, Fineberg NA. Overlap of obsessive-compulsive personality disorder and autism spectrum disorder traits among OCD outpatients: an exploratory study. Int J Psychiatry Clin Pract. 2019 Nov;23(4):297-306. . Epub 2019 Aug 2. PMID: 31375037.
Gadelkarim, W., Shahper, S., Reid, J., Wikramanayake, M., Kaur, S., Kolli, S., ... & Osman, S. (2017). Obsessive compulsive personality disorder and autism spectrum disorder traits in the obsessive-compulsive disorder clinic. European Psychiatry, 41(S1), S135-S136.
Honda, K. J. Psychology in Seattle Podcast. Obsessive Compulsive Personality Disorder. January, 2022.
Lai, M. C., & Baron-Cohen, S. (2015). Identifying the lost generation of adults with autism spectrum conditions. The Lancet Psychiatry, 2(11), 1013-1027.
Marincowitz C, Lochner C, Stein DJ. The neurobiology of obsessive–compulsive personality disorder: a systematic review. CNS Spectrums. 2022;27(6):664-675. doi:10.1017/S1092852921000754
McWilliams, N. (2011). Psychoanalytic diagnosis: Understanding personality structure in the clinical process. Guilford Press.
Pozza, Andrea PhD; Starcevic, Vladan PhD; Ferretti, Fabio MStat; Pedani, Carolina BSN; Crispino, Roberta BSN; Governi, Guido BSN; Luchi, Simonetta BSN; Gallorini, Antonella BSN; Lochner, Christine PhD; Coluccia, Anna MLaw. Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Disorder Co-occurring in Individuals with Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Harvard Review of Psychiatry 29(2):p 95-107, 3/4 2021.
Rizvi A, Torrico TJ. Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Disorder. [Updated 2023 Oct 28]. In: StatPearls [Internet]. Treasure Island (FL): StatPearls Publishing; 2024 Jan-. Available from: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK597372/
Rowland TA, Jainer AK, Panchal R. Living with obsessional personality. BJ Psych Bull. 2017 Dec;41(6):366-367.
Starcevic V, Brakoulias V. New diagnostic perspectives on obsessive-compulsive personality disorder and its links with other conditions. Curr Opin Psychiatry. 2014 Jan;27 (1):62-7.
